• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Lisa Schwartz

  • Home
  • About Lisa
  • Day in the Life of Marketer Posts
  • Contact Me
Home › A Day in the Life of a VP of Marketing › Your Teams Can Hit Every KPI and Still Miss the Growth Goal
Your Teams Can Hit Every KPI and Still Miss the Growth Goal

Your Teams Can Hit Every KPI and Still Miss the Growth Goal

August 23, 2026 By Lisa Schwartz

Marketing generated 5,000 leads.

Sales completed its activity target.

Customer success maintained its retention rate.

Product increased usage.

Finance protected margin.

Everyone hit a metric. The company still missed its growth goal.

This happens more often than leaders want to admit. Every team has a dashboard. Every function has priorities. Everyone appears busy and productive. But the organization is still not moving toward one clearly defined business outcome.

That is the problem we address in the Reframe stage of my Growth Framework.

In Gauge, we measured the current state. We looked at performance, spend, technology, team capabilities, pipeline, conversion rates, customer retention, and the other metrics shaping growth.

In Reframe, we make a harder decision.

Of everything we can measure, what matters most right now?

The Walk Can Have One Destination and Still Go in Three Directions

I see this problem every time I walk Dusty and Tanner.

Dusty sees a squirrel.

Tanner discovers an interesting smell.

I am trying to get home.

Technically, we are all on the same walk. Operationally, we have three different priorities.

A business can work exactly the same way.

Marketing optimizes lead volume. Sales optimizes bookings. Customer success optimizes retention. Product optimizes usage. Finance watches margin.

Each team may be doing exactly what it was asked to do. But if those metrics do not connect to the same growth outcome, the organization starts pulling in different directions.

Activity increases. Reports get longer. Meetings multiply. Growth still stalls.

That is why one of the most important decisions in Reframe is choosing a North Star metric.

What Is a North Star Metric?

A North Star metric is the primary business outcome that keeps the organization focused on the same growth priority.

Think of it as the main leash connecting the company to its destination.

It should not be a vanity metric. Website traffic is probably not your North Star. Neither are impressions, social engagement, MQLs, campaign launches, sales calls, or product releases.

Those metrics can be useful. They may tell you whether a particular activity is working. But they do not necessarily tell you whether the company is creating meaningful growth.

A useful North Star metric represents an important business outcome that multiple teams can influence.

Depending on the company’s growth constraint, that metric might be:

🐕 Qualified pipeline created in the priority market

🐕 Pipeline velocity

🐕 Expansion ARR

🐕 Time from qualified opportunity to revenue

🐕 Revenue generated from a strategically important customer segment

The correct metric depends on the problem the business needs to solve.

If the primary constraint is a 14-month sales cycle, generating more top-of-funnel leads may not fix it. The company may need to focus on reducing the time required to move qualified opportunities to revenue.

If customer acquisition is strong but growth is being lost through weak retention and limited expansion, the North Star may need to focus on expansion ARR.

If the company is pursuing too many markets and failing to gain traction in any of them, the North Star could be qualified pipeline created within a clearly defined priority market.

Do not pick the metric that is easiest to report. Pick the one that best represents the growth outcome the organization needs to change.

One North Star Does Not Mean One Metric

Choosing one North Star does not mean throwing away every other KPI.

It means creating a clear hierarchy.

Suppose the company wants to add $20 million in ARR. Leadership should be able to work backward from that destination.

How much qualified pipeline will be required?

What win rate does the company need?

How quickly must opportunities progress?

How many qualified accounts need to enter the buying journey?

How much revenue must come from new customers?

How much must come from retention and expansion?

Those become the supporting metrics underneath the North Star.

The North Star tells the company where it is going. Supporting metrics explain how each team helps it get there.

Marketing can connect campaigns to qualified pipeline in the priority market.

Sales can connect activity to opportunity progression, win rate, and revenue velocity.

Customer success can connect adoption and account engagement to retention and expansion.

Product can connect usage to customer value and growth.

RevOps can make sure the definitions, systems, and measurements are consistent.

Finance can determine whether growth is being created with acceptable economics.

Now the teams are not simply reporting separate accomplishments. They are showing how their work moves a shared business outcome.

The North Star Changes the Questions

Without a North Star, marketing might report:

“We generated 5,000 leads.”

With a North Star, the leadership team asks:

Did those leads create qualified pipeline in the market we agreed mattered most?

Sales might report:

“We exceeded our activity target.”

The better question becomes:

Did those activities move the right opportunities faster?

Product might report:

“Usage increased.”

The North Star forces the company to ask:

Did the increased usage improve retention, expansion, or another agreed growth outcome?

This does not make the supporting metrics irrelevant. It gives them context.

A lead target, sales activity target, product adoption metric, or retention metric becomes more valuable when the organization can explain how it contributes to the same destination.

What About Brand, Customer Experience, and Category Creation?

Not every important investment generates revenue tomorrow.

Brand matters.

Customer experience matters.

Category creation matters.

A company should not stop investing in long-term growth simply because an activity cannot be connected to immediate revenue.

But leadership should be able to explain how the investment supports the shared growth objective.

For example, a category creation initiative might increase recognition and consideration within the company’s priority accounts. That increased consideration could improve engagement, opportunity creation, or sales velocity.

A customer experience program might increase adoption, renewal, referrals, or expansion.

A brand campaign might improve the company’s ability to enter buying conversations with target accounts.

The connection may not be immediate, but it should not be imaginary.

“Brand” cannot become a permanent exemption from business accountability.

Walk the North Star Dog

This is another version of what I mean when I say, “Let’s walk the dog.”

Put the destination on the whiteboard.

Then put the North Star metric underneath it.

From there, map the supporting metrics, initiatives, owners, and dependencies required to move that number.

Ask:

🐕 What business outcome must change for the company to reach its growth goal?

🐕 What is currently preventing that outcome from changing?

🐕 Which single metric best represents progress against that constraint?

🐕 How does each function contribute to that metric?

🐕 Which initiatives have no clear connection to the agreed growth outcome?

That last question may be the most uncomfortable.

Organizations accumulate campaigns, technology, reports, meetings, programs, and pet projects. Some once supported an important priority. Others were launched because a competitor was doing something similar or an executive wanted to test an idea.

Over time, those activities become part of the operating rhythm even when no one can explain what growth outcome they support.

Mapping initiatives to the North Star exposes that disconnect.

If an initiative does not connect, ask why the company is still doing it.

One Destination, One Primary Outcome

A North Star metric does not eliminate debate.

It improves the debate.

Instead of arguing about which team’s dashboard looks better, leaders can discuss which actions are most likely to move the agreed business outcome.

Instead of rewarding disconnected activity, they can prioritize work that advances the company’s growth strategy.

Instead of giving every team a different destination, they can align the organization around one shared result.

One destination. One primary outcome. A clear hierarchy of supporting metrics. One leash keeping the whole pack moving in the same direction.

Dog walked.

What metric is your company actually walking toward?

Check out the video to learn how.

About Lisa Schwartz

Avatar

A Day in the Life of a VP of Marketing shares articles and thought leadership as well as practical advice for marketing teams to create successful, memorable campaigns and build brands without making unnecessary mistakes.

Learn how to become a successful modern marketer and support marketing teams without squandering your time.

Sign up for my newsletter and receive updates on new blog posts. There I will help you discover smarter ways to create delightful brands and work with Sales better to generate more opportunities.

Primary Sidebar

A Day in the Life of a VP of Marketing

  • Your Teams Can Hit Every KPI and Still Miss the Growth Goal
  • Future-Back Growth Strategy: Turn the Map Around Before You Execute
  • Your TAM Is Probably Lying to You
  • Your AI Strategy Is Only as Good as the Data It Cannot Find
  • Why Your Dashboard Is Not a Growth Diagnosis

Want To Learn More?

ABM Account Based Marketing A Day in the Life of a VP of Marketing AI AI Growth Framework AI Marketing AI Strategy B2B Growth Strategy CAC ChatGPT Content Marketing Customer Acquisition Cost General Generative AI Growth Framework Growth Framework - Reframe Growth Marketing Integrated Marketing Campaigns Salesforce Reports Search Engine Optimization SEO Video Video Marketing Video SE VP Marketing Walking the Dogs Podcast YouTube

My Contact Info:

Schwartz
P.O. Box 24307
San Jose, CA 95154

 

About Lisa Schwartz

Lisa Schwartz drives innovative marketing transformation for top tech brands in the world, such as HP, AWS, Citrix, Oracle and Nortel. She is an author of “Guidebook To Digital Marketing and Customer Attraction,” and a sought-after speaker on executive marketing thought leadership, demand generation, marketing operations, global marketing, ABM and AI use cases in Marketing. In her free time, she writes about how executives can harness the power of AI in their marketing teams. Learn More

  • Home
  • About Lisa
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

© Copyright 2026 Lisa Schwartz - Day in the Life of a VP of Marketing · All Rights Reserved ·Terms of Use · Privacy